The Portland Rhinoplasty Center THe Portland Rhinoplasty CEnter

Open Versus Closed Rhinoplasty

Open Versus Closed Rhinoplasty

The nose is one of the most prominent features on the face. For those who are dissatisfied with the shape and size of their noses, plastic surgery procedures, such as rhinoplasty, can help. Not all rhinoplasty techniques are created equal; there are advantages and disadvantages to both open and closed rhinoplasties. In this article, we will discuss what open versus closed rhinoplasty involves and how to decide which one is best for you.

The contours of the nose play an important role in our overall facial appearance, so it’s no surprise that many people are unhappy with theirs. Rhinoplasty is a surgical procedure that can reshape the nose by altering its size or shape. There are two primary approaches to rhinoplasty: open and closed. Each approach has its pros and cons that should be discussed with your surgeon before deciding which route is right for you.

Open and closed rhinoplasties differ in terms of incision placement, recovery time, scarring visibility, and more. We’ll explore these differences in detail below while providing tips on how to choose between them based on your individual needs. With this knowledge in hand, you’ll be able to make an informed decision about how to achieve your desired outcomes from a rhinoplasty procedure.


Rhinoplasty is a surgical procedure to change the shape, size, and/or appearance of the nose. Open rhinoplasty and closed rhinoplasty are two different approaches used in this procedure. In open rhinoplasty, the surgeon makes an incision across the columella (the strip of tissue separating the nostrils) to gain access to the nasal structures. In closed rhinoplasty, all incisions are made within the nostril openings.

Open rhinoplasty gives surgeons greater visibility and access to the underlying structures of the nose during surgery. It can help them better reshape and reposition certain parts of the nose for improved aesthetic results. Closed rhinoplasty is less invasive than open rhinoplasty and does not leave any visible scarring on the outside of your nose. It also allows surgeons to refine areas within your nose that may be difficult to reach with open rhinoplasty techniques.

Your surgeon will recommend one method over another depending on your individual needs and goals for surgery. They will discuss both procedures with you in order to make an informed decision about which type of rhinoplasty is right for you.

What Is Involved In Each Procedure?

Open and closed rhinoplasty procedures involve different techniques and approaches to reshaping the nose. In an open rhinoplasty, an incision is made across the columella – the strip of skin that separates the nostrils. This allows for greater accessibility to manipulate the underlying structures of the nose, giving surgeons more control over reshaping it. Meanwhile, a closed rhinoplasty does not require any external incisions. Instead, all of the work is done through incisions within the nostrils themselves.

In both open and closed rhinoplasty procedures, surgeons can correct structural deficiencies in order to create a more aesthetically pleasing nose shape. However, each procedure has its own advantages and disadvantages. Open rhinoplasties allow for greater precision when manipulating the internal structures of the nose and provide easier access for complex nasal reshaping tasks such as grafts or implants. On the other hand, closed rhinoplasties are usually less invasive and can be completed more quickly than open procedures because no external incisions are needed.

Although both open and closed rhinoplasties can improve one’s appearance by correcting structural flaws or improving symmetry, they each have their own unique advantages and disadvantages depending on one’s individual needs. It’s important to speak with your surgeon about which procedure might best meet your aesthetic goals before undergoing surgery.

Benefits Of Open Rhinoplasty

Open rhinoplasty offers a number of advantages over closed rhinoplasty. The most important benefit is that it allows for a more thorough reshaping of the nose. During an open procedure, the surgeon has direct access to all parts of the nasal structure, allowing them to make extensive changes and adjustments as needed. This can be beneficial for patients who have severe deformities, asymmetries, or other complex issues with their nose.

The second major benefit of an open rhinoplasty is that it gives surgeons greater control over the final outcome. By having a better view inside the nose, they are able to more accurately predict how the changes they make will affect its overall shape and appearance. Additionally, this allows them to make minor adjustments during surgery if necessary in order to achieve a desired result.

Finally, open rhinoplasty also provides improved visibility for surgeons which can help reduce potential complications and ensure that the desired outcome is achieved. This improved visibility makes it easier for doctors to see any potential problems before they arise and take corrective action quickly and efficiently if needed.

Benefits Of Closed Rhinoplasty

Closed rhinoplasty involves making incisions inside the nose, rather than on the outside. This procedure offers several benefits to the patient.

First, closed rhinoplasty is less invasive than open rhinoplasty and requires a shorter recovery time. Because there are no external incisions, there is also no visible scarring after the procedure. It’s also much easier to maintain a natural appearance with this type of rhinoplasty; because all changes are made from within the nose, they can be more precisely controlled.

The second benefit of closed rhinoplasty is that it can be done quickly and with fewer complications than open rhinoplasty. Since only internal tissue needs to be manipulated, the risk of infection or other complications is minimized. Furthermore, since all work is done from inside the nose, there’s less risk of damaging the delicate nasal structures during surgery.

Overall, closed rhinoplasty offers a number of advantages for patients looking to reduce or alter their nose shape without needing to go through an extensive surgical procedure. With fewer risks involved and a shorter recovery period, it’s often considered a better option than open rhinoplasty for many individuals seeking facial plastic surgery.

Risks Of Open Rhinoplasty

Open rhinoplasty is a surgical procedure that involves making an incision across the columella, the tissue between the nostrils. While there are some benefits to this procedure, it also carries certain risks. These include noticeable scarring, increased risk of infection, and complications with healing.

Scarring is one of the most common risks associated with open rhinoplasty. This procedure requires a larger incision than closed rhinoplasty, which means there will be more visible scarring afterwards. Although these scars can typically be hidden by makeup or clothing, they may still be visible for several months following surgery.

Patients who undergo open rhinoplasty are also at an increased risk of developing infections after their surgery. The larger incision increases the potential for bacteria to enter the wound, which can lead to serious complications if left untreated. Additionally, open rhinoplasty requires more manipulation of the tissue surrounding the nose, which can make healing more difficult and increase the chances of infection occurring.

Finally, because open rhinoplasty involves a larger incision and more tissue manipulation than closed rhinoplasty, it also carries a higher risk of complications during recovery. These complications can range from minor pain and discomfort to severe swelling and bruising that could last longer than expected. For this reason, patients should be sure to follow all post-operative instructions closely in order to minimize these risks as much as possible.

Risks Of Closed Rhinoplasty

Closed rhinoplasty is considered to be less invasive than open rhinoplasty and involves an incision made inside the nostrils. While this method of nose reshaping has many benefits, there are also potential risks involved.

The most common risks associated with closed rhinoplasty include infection, scarring, and difficulty breathing. During the procedure, bacteria can enter the incision sites and cause infection. In addition, scarring may occur within the nostrils or around the nasal base due to tissue manipulation during the operation. Even though these issues are rare, they can still cause serious complications if not addressed promptly.

Furthermore, some patients may experience difficulty breathing through their noses following a closed rhinoplasty procedure. This is often caused by swelling or misalignment of septal cartilage, which can impair airflow through the nasal cavities. If this occurs, it is important to consult a plastic surgeon who can determine appropriate treatment options to restore normal airflow in the nose.

In summary, closed rhinoplasty carries certain risks that should be taken into consideration before undergoing surgery. Patients should be aware of these potential risks and discuss them with their doctor before proceeding with the procedure.

Cost Comparison

The cost associated with open and closed rhinoplasty can vary depending on the type of procedure, complexity, and geographical location. Open rhinoplasty is typically more expensive due to its level of complexity. It requires a more extensive incision and often involves grafting procedures in order to achieve the desired results. In contrast, closed rhinoplasty requires a smaller incision, making it a less expensive option.

When researching the costs associated with either procedure, it is important to understand what factors are included in the overall price tag. These may include surgeon fees, operating room fees, anesthesia fees, post-operative care and recovery time, hospital stay fees or any additional procedures that may be required during surgery. Patients should also keep in mind that there may be additional costs such as medication or follow-up visits that need to be taken into account.

It is strongly recommended that patients consult with their physician to ensure they fully understand all of the associated costs with both open and closed rhinoplasty before making their choice. Ultimately, each patient’s budget will determine which type of nose surgery is right for them.

Who Is A Good Candidate For Each Method?

Open rhinoplasty is typically recommended for those who need more complex surgical alterations. It may be used to address breathing problems, to reduce the size of the nose, or to reshape the bridge or tip of the nose. Open rhinoplasty also gives surgeons greater access and control over the nasal structures.

Closed rhinoplasty is generally reserved for patients who require minor changes in their noses. This type of surgery only involves incisions made inside the nostrils, so there are no visible scars after healing. It can be used to change the shape of a person’s nose, reduce its size, or narrow its bridge.

Patients should discuss their individual needs and goals with their surgeon before deciding which method is best for them. The surgeon will consider the patient’s overall health and facial anatomy when determining which technique will provide optimal results.

Recovery And Aftercare

Recovery from a rhinoplasty procedure depends on whether it is an open or closed approach. Generally, the recovery period for an open rhinoplasty takes longer than that of a closed rhinoplasty. Pain and swelling are common, regardless of the approach used.

Patients who have undergone an open rhinoplasty should expect to experience bruising and swelling in the area around their eyes and nose for 1-2 weeks after surgery. It is important to keep the head elevated during this time to help reduce swelling. Patients may also experience difficulty breathing through the nose at first, but this is generally temporary. It is important to follow post-operative instructions carefully, including applying any ointments or dressings as directed by their surgeon.

After undergoing a closed rhinoplasty procedure, most patients will only experience redness and swelling in the nose area that gradually fades over time. In some cases, patients may be able to return to work or school within 2-3 days following surgery. As with any surgical procedure, it is important for patients to take proper care of themselves during their recovery period by getting plenty of rest and avoiding strenuous activities such as exercising until cleared by their doctor.

It is essential for patients to follow all post-surgery instructions carefully for optimal results following their rhinoplasty procedure. It can take several months for all of the results from either an open or closed rhinoplasty procedure to be visible; however, patients can usually begin enjoying noticeable changes within a few weeks after surgery.

Choosing The Right Option

When it comes to rhinoplasty, patients must carefully consider their options. Open and closed rhinoplasty are two of the most common procedures available. Both offer unique benefits and should be discussed with a qualified plastic surgeon.

Open rhinoplasty involves making an incision along the columella, which is the strip of tissue that separates the nostrils. This allows greater access to the underlying structures, enabling more precise modifications of cartilage and bone. However, this method also leaves a visible scar across the base of the nose.

Closed rhinoplasty is a less invasive option that relies on hidden incisions inside of the nostrils. As a result, there are no external scars associated with this procedure. The main downside is that it provides limited access to cartilage and bone structure, making it unsuitable for complex cases such as large hump removal or revisional surgery.

Both open and closed rhinoplasty have advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important for patients to discuss their options with their surgeon in order to decide which procedure best meets their needs.

When it comes to rhinoplasty, there are two main techniques: open and closed. Both procedures involve different techniques, risks, and benefits. It is important to consider all of these factors before deciding which is the best option for you.

Open rhinoplasty offers more access to the nasal tissues, allowing for greater control over reshaping the nose. However, it also requires a longer recovery period and may result in more noticeable scarring than closed rhinoplasty. Closed rhinoplasty has a shorter recovery time and less visible scarring, but provides less control over reshaping the nose.

Ultimately, the decision about which type of rhinoplasty is best for you will depend on your individual needs, preferences, anatomy and budget. Your plastic surgeon can help you understand what each technique entails so that you can make an informed decision about which procedure will yield the results you desire.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


We are here to help you. Learn more about who we are and what we do.


Ask Us A Question About Nose Surgery Make An Appointment New Patient Forms

    Schedule a Rhinoplasty Consultation Today